implementation-final-review

Review completed implementation changes before final verification. Use when repository policy requires independent review or the user explicitly requests it.

Install
npx skills add 'https://github.com/openai/openai-agents-js/tree/main/.agents/skills/implementation-final-review'
Download bundle ↓
main · 506f736Scanned 2026-09-17

Contributors

GitHub-linked commit authors for this SKILL.md at the saved revision. Co-authors and history before file renames are not included.

File history ↗
View on GitHub
← Back to SKILL.md
#!/usr/bin/env python3"""Print deterministic content and repository fingerprints for a review state.""" from __future__ import annotations import argparseimport hashlibimport jsonimport osimport reimport statimport subprocessimport tempfilefrom dataclasses import dataclassfrom pathlib import Path, PurePosixPath  def _git(repo: Path, *args: str) -> bytes:    return subprocess.check_output(        ("git", "-C", os.fspath(repo), *args), stderr=subprocess.PIPE    )  def _git_diff(repo: Path, *args: str) -> bytes:    completed = subprocess.run(        ("git", "-C", os.fspath(repo), *args),        capture_output=True,    )    if completed.returncode not in {0, 1}:        raise subprocess.CalledProcessError(            completed.returncode,            completed.args,            output=completed.stdout,            stderr=completed.stderr,        )    return completed.stdout  def _digest(data: bytes) -> str:    return hashlib.sha256(data).hexdigest()  @dataclass(frozen=True, slots=True)class _Snapshot:    tracked_diff: bytes    complete_diff: bytes    status: bytes    workspace: list[dict[str, object]]    unfiltered_status: bytes    unfiltered_workspace: list[dict[str, object]]    component_workspaces: dict[str, list[dict[str, object]]]  class _NonRegularFileError(ValueError):    pass  def _nonblocking_opener(path: str, flags: int) -> int:    return os.open(path, flags | getattr(os, "O_NONBLOCK", 0))  def _read_regular_file(path: Path) -> tuple[bytes, os.stat_result]:    with open(path, "rb", opener=_nonblocking_opener) as file:        file_stat = os.fstat(file.fileno())        if not stat.S_ISREG(file_stat.st_mode):            raise _NonRegularFileError(path)        return file.read(), file_stat  def _unsafe_index_paths(repo: Path) -> tuple[tuple[str, str], ...]:    raw_entries = _git(repo, "ls-files", "-v", "-z")    unsafe_paths: list[tuple[str, str]] = []    for entry in raw_entries.split(b"\0"):        if len(entry) < 3 or entry[1:2] != b" ":            continue        tag = entry[:1]        relative_path = os.fsdecode(entry[2:])        if tag.islower():            unsafe_paths.append(("assume-unchanged", relative_path))        elif tag == b"S":            candidate = repo / relative_path            if candidate.exists() or candidate.is_symlink():                unsafe_paths.append(("materialized skip-worktree", relative_path))    for entry in _git(repo, "ls-files", "--unmerged", "-z").split(b"\0"):        _, separator, raw_path = entry.partition(b"\t")        if separator:            unsafe_paths.append(("unmerged", os.fsdecode(raw_path)))    return tuple(sorted(set(unsafe_paths)))  def _require_reviewable_index(repo: Path, context: str = "repository") -> None:    unsafe_paths = _unsafe_index_paths(repo)    if unsafe_paths:        details = ", ".join(f"{kind}={path}" for kind, path in unsafe_paths)        raise ValueError(f"The {context} contains unsupported index state: {details}")  def _index_gitlinks(repo: Path) -> dict[str, str]:    raw_entries = _git(repo, "ls-files", "--stage", "-z")    gitlinks: dict[str, str] = {}    for raw_entry in raw_entries.split(b"\0"):        metadata, separator, raw_path = raw_entry.partition(b"\t")        fields = metadata.split()        if separator and len(fields) == 3 and fields[0] == b"160000" and fields[2] == b"0":            gitlinks[os.fsdecode(raw_path)] = fields[1].decode()    return gitlinks  def _is_repository_root(path: Path) -> bool:    try:        top_level = _git(path, "rev-parse", "--show-toplevel")    except (subprocess.CalledProcessError, FileNotFoundError):        return False    return Path(os.fsdecode(top_level.rstrip(b"\n"))).resolve() == path.resolve()  def _require_clean_submodule(    repo: Path,    display_path: str,    expected_head: str,    ancestors: frozenset[Path],) -> None:    resolved_repo = repo.resolve()    if resolved_repo in ancestors:        raise ValueError(f"Cyclic submodule worktree is unsupported: {display_path}")    ancestors |= {resolved_repo}    _require_reviewable_index(repo, f"submodule {display_path}")    actual_head = _git(repo, "rev-parse", "HEAD^{commit}").decode().strip()    if actual_head != expected_head:        raise ValueError(f"Submodule HEAD does not match the parent index: {display_path}")    for nested_relative_path, nested_head in _index_gitlinks(repo).items():        nested_path = repo / nested_relative_path        _require_clean_gitlink(            nested_path,            f"{display_path}/{nested_relative_path}",            nested_head,            ancestors,        )    if _git(        repo,        "status",        "--porcelain=v1",        "-z",        "--untracked-files=all",        "--ignore-submodules=none",    ):        raise ValueError(f"Dirty submodule worktrees are unsupported: {display_path}")  def _require_clean_gitlink(    path: Path,    display_path: str,    expected_head: str,    ancestors: frozenset[Path],) -> None:    if _is_repository_root(path):        _require_clean_submodule(path, display_path, expected_head, ancestors)    elif path.is_dir() and any(path.iterdir()):        raise ValueError(f"Materialized gitlink is not an initialized submodule: {display_path}")  def _require_clean_submodules(repo: Path) -> None:    ancestors = frozenset({repo.resolve()})    for relative_path, expected_head in _index_gitlinks(repo).items():        _require_clean_gitlink(            repo / relative_path,            relative_path,            expected_head,            ancestors,        )  def _write_bytes_atomically(path: Path, data: bytes) -> None:    descriptor, temporary_name = tempfile.mkstemp(        prefix=".review-state-diff-",        dir=path.parent,    )    try:        with os.fdopen(descriptor, "wb") as temporary_file:            temporary_file.write(data)        os.replace(temporary_name, path)    finally:        try:            os.unlink(temporary_name)        except FileNotFoundError:            pass  def _directory_is_within(path: Path, root: Path) -> bool:    current = path    while True:        try:            if current.samefile(root):                return True        except OSError:            pass        parent = current.parent        if parent == current:            return False        current = parent  def _canonical_pathspecs(pathspecs: tuple[str, ...]) -> tuple[str, ...]:    canonical: list[str] = []    seen: set[str] = set()    for pathspec in pathspecs:        if not pathspec:            raise ValueError("Pathspecs must not be empty.")        if "\0" in pathspec:            raise ValueError("Pathspecs must not contain NUL bytes.")        if pathspec not in seen:            canonical.append(pathspec)            seen.add(pathspec)    return tuple(canonical)  def _base_has_literal_path(repo: Path, base: str, pathspec: str) -> bool:    raw_path = os.fsencode(pathspec)    entries = _git(        repo,        "ls-tree",        "-z",        base,        "--",        f":(literal){pathspec}",    )    for entry in entries.split(b"\0"):        metadata, separator, entry_path = entry.partition(b"\t")        fields = metadata.split()        if separator and entry_path == raw_path and len(fields) >= 2 and fields[1] != b"tree":            return True    return False  def _load_pathspec_file(path: Path) -> tuple[str, ...]:    try:        data, _ = _read_regular_file(path)        values = [line for line in data.decode().splitlines() if line]    except (OSError, UnicodeError, ValueError) as error:        raise ValueError(f"Cannot read pathspec file {path}: {error}") from error    return _canonical_pathspecs(tuple(values))  def _read_workspace_file(path: Path, relative_path: str) -> tuple[bytes, os.stat_result]:    try:        return _read_regular_file(path)    except _NonRegularFileError as error:        raise ValueError(f"Unsupported workspace file type: {relative_path}") from error    except OSError as error:        raise ValueError(f"Cannot read workspace file: {relative_path}") from error  def _workspace_entry(repo: Path, relative_path: str) -> dict[str, object]:    path = repo / relative_path    if path.is_symlink():        content = b"symlink\0" + os.fsencode(os.readlink(path))        return {            "path": relative_path,            "kind": "symlink",            "sha256": _digest(content),        }    if path.is_file():        file_content, file_stat = _read_workspace_file(path, relative_path)        content = b"file\0" + file_content        return {            "path": relative_path,            "kind": "file",            "executable": bool(file_stat.st_mode & 0o100),            "sha256": _digest(content),        }    indexed_head = _index_gitlinks(repo).get(relative_path)    if path.is_dir():        if indexed_head is not None:            return {                "path": relative_path,                "kind": "gitlink",                "head": indexed_head,            }        if _is_repository_root(path):            raise ValueError(f"Untracked nested Git repositories are unsupported: {relative_path}")        return {"path": relative_path, "kind": "directory"}    if indexed_head is not None:        return {            "path": relative_path,            "kind": "gitlink",            "head": indexed_head,        }    if path.exists():        raise ValueError(f"Unsupported workspace file type: {relative_path}")    return {"path": relative_path, "kind": "missing"}  def _workspace_entries(    repo: Path, base: str, pathspecs: tuple[str, ...]) -> list[dict[str, object]]:    git_pathspecs = _git_pathspecs(repo, base, pathspecs)    tracked_paths = _git(        repo,        "diff",        "--name-only",        "--no-renames",        "--ignore-submodules=none",        "-z",        base,        "--",        *git_pathspecs,    )    untracked_paths = _untracked_paths(repo, base, pathspecs)    paths = {        os.fsdecode(raw_path)        for raw_path in (*tracked_paths.split(b"\0"), *untracked_paths)        if raw_path    }    return [_workspace_entry(repo, relative_path) for relative_path in sorted(paths)]  def _untracked_paths(repo: Path, base: str, pathspecs: tuple[str, ...]) -> tuple[bytes, ...]:    literal_pathspecs = _literal_pathspecs(repo, base, pathspecs)    raw_paths = _git(        repo,        "ls-files",        "--others",        "--exclude-standard",        "-z",        "--",        *_git_pathspecs(repo, base, pathspecs, literal_pathspecs),    )    paths = {raw_path for raw_path in raw_paths.split(b"\0") if raw_path}    for pathspec in literal_pathspecs:        raw_path = os.fsencode(pathspec)        tracked_paths = _git(repo, "ls-files", "-z", "--", f":(literal){pathspec}")        if raw_path not in tracked_paths.split(b"\0"):            paths.add(raw_path)    return tuple(sorted(paths))  def _literal_pathspecs(repo: Path, base: str, pathspecs: tuple[str, ...]) -> frozenset[str]:    literal_pathspecs: set[str] = set()    for pathspec in pathspecs:        relative_path = PurePosixPath(pathspec)        if (            relative_path.is_absolute()            or pathspec != relative_path.as_posix()            or any(part in {".", ".."} for part in relative_path.parts)        ):            continue        candidate = repo.joinpath(*relative_path.parts)        raw_path = os.fsencode(pathspec)        tracked_paths = _git(repo, "ls-files", "-z", "--", f":(literal){pathspec}")        if (            (candidate.exists() and not candidate.is_dir())            or candidate.is_symlink()            or raw_path in tracked_paths.split(b"\0")            or _base_has_literal_path(repo, base, pathspec)        ):            literal_pathspecs.add(pathspec)    return frozenset(literal_pathspecs)  def _git_pathspecs(    repo: Path,    base: str,    pathspecs: tuple[str, ...],    literal_pathspecs: frozenset[str] | None = None,) -> tuple[str, ...]:    if literal_pathspecs is None:        literal_pathspecs = _literal_pathspecs(repo, base, pathspecs)    return tuple(        f":(literal){pathspec}" if pathspec in literal_pathspecs else pathspec        for pathspec in pathspecs    )  def _complete_diff(repo: Path, base: str, pathspecs: tuple[str, ...]) -> bytes:    chunks = [        _git(            repo,            "diff",            "--binary",            "--full-index",            "--ignore-submodules=none",            base,            "--",            *_git_pathspecs(repo, base, pathspecs),        )    ]    for raw_path in _untracked_paths(repo, base, pathspecs):        chunks.append(            _git_diff(                repo,                "diff",                "--no-index",                "--binary",                "--full-index",                "--",                "/dev/null",                os.fsdecode(raw_path),            )        )    return b"".join(chunks)  def _content_fingerprint(base: str, workspace: list[dict[str, object]]) -> str:    canonical = json.dumps(        {"base": base, "workspace": workspace},        ensure_ascii=True,        sort_keys=True,        separators=(",", ":"),    )    return _digest(canonical.encode())  def _repository_fingerprint(    *,    content_fingerprint: str,    head: str,    status_sha256: str,    tracked_diff_sha256: str,    complete_diff_sha256: str,    unfiltered_status_sha256: str,    unfiltered_content_fingerprint: str,) -> str:    canonical = json.dumps(        {            "content_fingerprint": content_fingerprint,            "head": head,            "status_sha256": status_sha256,            "tracked_diff_sha256": tracked_diff_sha256,            "complete_diff_sha256": complete_diff_sha256,            "unfiltered_status_sha256": unfiltered_status_sha256,            "unfiltered_content_fingerprint": unfiltered_content_fingerprint,        },        ensure_ascii=False,        sort_keys=True,        separators=(",", ":"),    )    return _digest(canonical.encode())  def _capture_snapshot(    repo: Path,    base: str,    pathspecs: tuple[str, ...],    components: dict[str, tuple[str, ...]],) -> _Snapshot:    workspace = _workspace_entries(repo, base, pathspecs)    unfiltered_workspace = _workspace_entries(repo, base, ())    unfiltered_by_path = {str(entry["path"]): entry for entry in unfiltered_workspace}    for entry in workspace:        unfiltered_by_path.setdefault(str(entry["path"]), entry)    unfiltered_workspace = [unfiltered_by_path[path] for path in sorted(unfiltered_by_path)]    component_workspaces = {        name: _workspace_entries(repo, base, component_pathspecs)        for name, component_pathspecs in components.items()    }    git_pathspecs = _git_pathspecs(repo, base, pathspecs)    return _Snapshot(        tracked_diff=_git(            repo,            "diff",            "--binary",            "--full-index",            "--ignore-submodules=none",            base,            "--",            *git_pathspecs,        ),        complete_diff=_complete_diff(repo, base, pathspecs),        status=_git(            repo,            "status",            "--porcelain=v1",            "-z",            "--untracked-files=all",            "--ignore-submodules=none",            "--",            *git_pathspecs,        ),        workspace=workspace,        unfiltered_status=_git(            repo,            "status",            "--porcelain=v1",            "-z",            "--untracked-files=all",            "--ignore-submodules=none",        ),        unfiltered_workspace=unfiltered_workspace,        component_workspaces=component_workspaces,    )  def review_state(    repo: Path,    base: str,    pathspecs: tuple[str, ...] = (),    components: dict[str, tuple[str, ...]] | None = None,    complete_diff_output: Path | None = None,) -> dict[str, object]:    repo = repo.resolve()    top_level = Path(        os.fsdecode(_git(repo, "rev-parse", "--show-toplevel").rstrip(b"\n"))    ).resolve()    if not top_level.samefile(repo):        raise ValueError(f"Repository path must be the worktree root: {top_level}")    if complete_diff_output is not None:        complete_diff_output = complete_diff_output.expanduser().resolve()        if _directory_is_within(complete_diff_output.parent, repo):            raise ValueError("Complete diff output must be outside the repository.")    _require_reviewable_index(repo)    _require_clean_submodules(repo)    pathspecs = _canonical_pathspecs(pathspecs)    if components and not pathspecs:        pathspecs = _canonical_pathspecs(            tuple(                pathspec                for component_pathspecs in components.values()                for pathspec in component_pathspecs            )        )    resolved_base = _git(repo, "rev-parse", f"{base}^{{commit}}").decode().strip()    head = _git(repo, "rev-parse", "HEAD^{commit}").decode().strip()    try:        _git(repo, "merge-base", "--is-ancestor", resolved_base, head)    except subprocess.CalledProcessError as error:        raise ValueError("Base must be an ancestor of HEAD.") from error    canonical_components: dict[str, tuple[str, ...]] = {}    for name, component_pathspecs in sorted((components or {}).items()):        canonical_component_pathspecs = _canonical_pathspecs(component_pathspecs)        if not canonical_component_pathspecs:            raise ValueError(f"Component manifest is empty: {name}")        canonical_components[name] = canonical_component_pathspecs     snapshot = _capture_snapshot(repo, resolved_base, pathspecs, canonical_components)    _require_reviewable_index(repo)    _require_clean_submodules(repo)    final_snapshot = _capture_snapshot(repo, resolved_base, pathspecs, canonical_components)    final_head = _git(repo, "rev-parse", "HEAD^{commit}").decode().strip()    _require_reviewable_index(repo)    _require_clean_submodules(repo)    if final_head != head or final_snapshot != snapshot:        raise ValueError("Repository changed while review state was captured.")    snapshot = final_snapshot     content_fingerprint = _content_fingerprint(resolved_base, snapshot.workspace)    component_states: dict[str, dict[str, object]] = {}    component_owners: dict[str, list[str]] = {}    for name, canonical_component_pathspecs in canonical_components.items():        component_workspace = snapshot.component_workspaces[name]        for entry in component_workspace:            component_owners.setdefault(str(entry["path"]), []).append(name)        component_states[name] = {            "content_fingerprint": _content_fingerprint(                resolved_base, component_workspace            ),            "pathspecs": list(canonical_component_pathspecs),            "workspace": component_workspace,        }    if component_states:        combined_paths = {str(entry["path"]) for entry in snapshot.workspace}        component_paths = set(component_owners)        missing_paths = sorted(combined_paths - component_paths)        extra_paths = sorted(component_paths - combined_paths)        overlapping_paths = {            path: owners for path, owners in component_owners.items() if len(owners) > 1        }        if missing_paths or extra_paths or overlapping_paths:            raise ValueError(                "Component manifests must partition the combined review content exactly: "                f"missing={missing_paths}, extra={extra_paths}, "                f"overlapping={overlapping_paths}"            )     repository_state = {        "content_fingerprint": content_fingerprint,        "head": head,        "status_sha256": _digest(snapshot.status),        "tracked_diff_sha256": _digest(snapshot.tracked_diff),        "complete_diff_sha256": _digest(snapshot.complete_diff),    }    repository_fingerprint = _repository_fingerprint(        **repository_state,        unfiltered_status_sha256=_digest(snapshot.unfiltered_status),        unfiltered_content_fingerprint=_content_fingerprint(            resolved_base, snapshot.unfiltered_workspace        ),    )    if complete_diff_output is not None:        _write_bytes_atomically(complete_diff_output, snapshot.complete_diff)    return {        "fingerprint": content_fingerprint,        "content_fingerprint": content_fingerprint,        "repository_fingerprint": repository_fingerprint,        "base": resolved_base,        "pathspecs": list(pathspecs),        "workspace": snapshot.workspace,        "complete_diff_paths": [str(entry["path"]) for entry in snapshot.workspace],        "components": component_states,        "unfiltered": {            "status_sha256": _digest(snapshot.unfiltered_status),            "workspace": snapshot.unfiltered_workspace,        },        **repository_state,    }  def _parse_component_files(values: list[str]) -> dict[str, tuple[str, ...]]:    components: dict[str, tuple[str, ...]] = {}    for value in values:        name, separator, raw_path = value.partition("=")        if (            not separator            or not re.fullmatch(r"[a-z0-9][a-z0-9-]*", name)            or not raw_path        ):            raise ValueError(                "Component pathspec files must use lowercase NAME=FILE with a nonempty file."            )        if name in components:            raise ValueError(f"Duplicate component name: {name}")        components[name] = _load_pathspec_file(Path(raw_path))    return components  def _component(value: str) -> tuple[str, str]:    name, separator, pathspec = value.partition("=")    if not separator or not re.fullmatch(r"[a-z0-9][a-z0-9-]*", name) or not pathspec:        raise argparse.ArgumentTypeError("component must use lowercase NAME=PATHSPEC")    if "\0" in pathspec:        raise argparse.ArgumentTypeError(            "component pathspec must not contain NUL bytes"        )    return name, pathspec  def main() -> None:    parser = argparse.ArgumentParser()    parser.add_argument(        "--base", required=True, help="Resolved merge-base commit or revision."    )    parser.add_argument(        "--pathspec",        action="append",        default=[],        help="Task-owned Git pathspec. Repeat to scope the review; omit to include all changes.",    )    parser.add_argument(        "--pathspec-file",        action="append",        default=[],        type=Path,        help="File containing canonical task-owned pathspecs, one per line.",    )    parser.add_argument(        "--component-pathspec-file",        action="append",        default=[],        metavar="NAME=FILE",        help="Named component manifest. Repeat for runtime, tests-examples, or metadata.",    )    parser.add_argument(        "--component",        action="append",        default=[],        type=_component,        metavar="NAME=PATHSPEC",        help="Named component pathspec. Repeat a name to group paths into one fingerprint.",    )    parser.add_argument(        "--repo",        type=Path,        default=Path.cwd(),        help="Repository worktree root path.",    )    parser.add_argument(        "--complete-diff-output",        type=Path,        help="Write the complete binary diff, including task-owned untracked files, to this path.",    )    parser.add_argument(        "--pretty", action="store_true", help="Pretty-print the JSON output."    )    args = parser.parse_args()    try:        loaded_pathspec_files = [            _load_pathspec_file(path) for path in args.pathspec_file        ]        if any(not pathspecs for pathspecs in loaded_pathspec_files):            raise ValueError(                "A supplied pathspec file must contain at least one pathspec."            )        file_pathspecs = tuple(            pathspec for pathspecs in loaded_pathspec_files for pathspec in pathspecs        )        pathspecs = _canonical_pathspecs((*args.pathspec, *file_pathspecs))        component_files = _parse_component_files(args.component_pathspec_file)        component_values: dict[str, list[str]] = {            name: list(component_pathspecs)            for name, component_pathspecs in component_files.items()        }        for name, pathspec in args.component:            component_values.setdefault(name, []).append(pathspec)        components = {            name: _canonical_pathspecs(tuple(component_pathspecs))            for name, component_pathspecs in component_values.items()        }        state = review_state(            args.repo,            args.base,            pathspecs,            components,            complete_diff_output=args.complete_diff_output,        )    except ValueError as error:        parser.error(str(error))    except subprocess.CalledProcessError as error:        parser.error(f"Git command failed with exit status {error.returncode}.")    except (OSError, UnicodeError) as error:        parser.error(f"Cannot inspect repository state: {error}")    print(        json.dumps(            state,            ensure_ascii=True,            indent=2 if args.pretty else None,            sort_keys=True,        )    )  if __name__ == "__main__":    main() 
Referenced from SKILL.md